arrow squid

Southern Calamari, Arrow Squid or Cuttlefish? How to Tell Them Apart in Australia

Cuttlefish glowing in dark water

Short answer: look at the fins. Southern calamari have fins that run the full length of the body. Arrow squid have a small arrowhead-shaped fin at the rear third only. Cuttlefish have a broad, flat body with an internal cuttlebone. All three take an egi.

The three animals Australians catch on egi

Name Species How to tell it Where and when
Southern calamari Sepioteuthis australis Fins run the full length of the mantle like a skirt. Thick, sweet, tender flesh. Southern Australia: Victoria, South Australia, Tasmania, southern NSW and southern WA. Bays, seagrass and reef, roughly 1 to 15 m. The main target for most southern egi anglers.
Gould's or arrow squid Nototodarus gouldi A small arrowhead-shaped fin on the rear third only. Longer, more torpedo-shaped, softer flesh. Open coast and deeper water. Commercial jigging fleets work out of Portland and Queenscliff in Victoria. Hits jigs hard, often at night under lights.
Cuttlefish Sepia spp. Broad, flat body with an internal cuttlebone. Deeper piers, such as Portsea in Victoria, and reef edges.

In Victoria, "calamari" and "squid" usually mean the same thing: southern calamari. Elsewhere in Australia, and especially in northern waters, you may meet different squid species, so local advice matters.

Southern calamari: a one-year animal

Southern calamari live for roughly 12 months, so the whole population turns over every year. They spawn year-round with a spring and summer peak. Because size tracks age, the biggest individuals appear as a cohort matures. In Port Phillip Bay that means spring, with fish of 2 to 2.5 kg in the southern bay and reports approaching 3 kg around Lonsdale Bight and Swan Bay in September.

Females lay finger-like egg strings at the base of seagrass. Research by the Victorian Fisheries Authority in Port Phillip found that mature calamari strongly prefer Amphibolis and Zostera seagrass for egg attachment, concentrated in the southern and western bay.

Tagged squid move long distances but tend to stay on a spawning ground for about a week before moving on. A hot spot can be hot for days and then empty, so recent reports beat old reputation.

What makes them feed

The working model, from cross-study research rather than a single published ranking, puts temperature first, then light and time of day, then water clarity. No study has found a clear direct effect of tide on feeding, but tide matters indirectly because it moves clean water in and dirty water out and sets the current.

That is why cold, clear water can fish so well even though warm water makes individual squid hungrier. Catch rate depends on how many squid are around, how well they can see your jig and how well you fish it, not on hunger alone. Squid hunt by sight, so clean water, low light and a settled wind matter more than the month. If the water is dirty at your first spot, move.

How to target each one

  • Southern calamari: weed edges, reef and seagrass from piers, jetties and rocks, using size 2.5 to 3.5 egi. See the egi size guide and technique guide.
  • Arrow squid: open coast and deeper water, often at night under lights. They hit jigs hard.
  • Cuttlefish: deeper piers such as Portsea and reef edges. They can come on egi too, so check how your state counts them in the bag.

Is it worth going tonight?

Our Squid Bite Forecast scores tonight's conditions for 62 preset Australian spots from live weather data and shows which factor carried or capped each score.

Rules and limits

Bag limits, size rules, licences and closures differ by state and species, and they change. Check your state agency before you go, such as the Victorian Fisheries Authority, WA DPIRD Fisheries, NSW DPIRD Fisheries or PIRSA in South Australia.

Ready to gear up? Browse squid jigs and eging rods, or ask us.

Reading next

Daiwa 26 Emeraldas MX IL interline egi rod
Angler casting from rocks at sunset

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.